Tool evaluation poll for Slack

Picking a tool by committee meeting is slow, and picking it alone means the team finds out about it on rollout day. A poll in the channel where the work happens gets you real input in a day, from the people who will live with the choice.

Run it in two rounds: a quick vote on what to trial, then a short survey after the trial. The second round is the one that matters, because by then people have opinions from use, not from landing pages.

When to use it
When your team is choosing between software tools and the people who will use it every day should have a say.
How often
Once per evaluation
Category
Decisions

Example polls

Paste any of these into the message box in Slack.

/poll "Which project trackers are worth a two-week trial?" "Tracker A" "Tracker B" "Tracker C" "Keep what we have"

Choice poll. Round one. Multiple picks allowed, so you learn which tools have support at all.

/poll "Which project trackers are worth a two-week trial?" "Tracker A" "Tracker B" "Tracker C" "Keep what we have"

Free

/poll "Tracker A trial feedback" "Two minutes, anonymous. Answer for the tool you trialled." anonymous close after 3 days --- "How easy was it to get started?" "Very hard" "Hard" "OK" "Easy" "Very easy" scale --- "Did it handle your real day-to-day work?" "Yes" "Mostly" "No" limit 1 --- "Would you keep using it?" "Yes" "Only with changes" "No" limit 1 --- "What got in your way?" short text optional

Survey (4 questions). Round two. The post-trial survey, anonymous, closing after three days.

/poll "Tracker A trial feedback" "Two minutes, anonymous. Answer for the tool you trialled." anonymous close after 3 days --- "How easy was it to get started?" "Very hard" "Hard" "OK" "Easy" "Very easy" scale --- "Did it handle your real day-to-day work?" "Yes" "Mostly" "No" limit 1 --- "Would you keep using it?" "Yes" "Only with changes" "No" limit 1 --- "What got in your way?" short text optional

Premium: surveys (several questions), closing automatically

AnonymousClose automatically: after 3 days

/poll "Which tracker should we adopt?" "Tracker A" "Tracker B" "Stay on our current tool" limit 1 close after 2 days remind 1 day before closing

Choice poll. The final pick. One vote each, a reminder, and a fixed close.

/poll "Which tracker should we adopt?" "Tracker A" "Tracker B" "Stay on our current tool" limit 1 close after 2 days remind 1 day before closing

Premium: vote limits, closing automatically, reminders

Limit votes: 1 per personClose automatically: after 2 daysReminder: 24 hours before closing

Round one, the shortlist

Before anyone trials anything, ask what to trial. List two to four candidates plus "Keep what we have". That last option matters: if half the team is happy with the current tool, you want to know before you spend a month migrating.

Allow several picks here. You are finding out which tools are worth anyone's time, not choosing the winner.

Round two, after the trial

Send the trial survey when the trial ends, not halfway through. Ask about the things that decide adoption: how fast people got started, whether it handled their real work, and whether they would keep using it. One rating question per tool, plus one free-text question for blockers, is enough.

Keep it anonymous. People are polite about the tool their manager picked to trial. Anonymous answers tell you what they actually think.

The final pick

End with a single-choice poll that closes on a schedule: limit 1 and close after 2 days (both Premium). One answer per person makes the count clean, and a fixed close stops the decision from drifting.

Post the result with your reasoning, especially if you pick against the vote because of cost or security. A decision people disagree with but understand lands far better than a silent override.

The mistake people make

Asking "Which tool do you prefer?" before anyone has used them. You get votes for the brand people have heard of. Trial first, vote second.

Questions

Should the final vote be binding?

Say up front whether it is. If cost, security or contract terms can overrule it, tell people before they vote, not after.

Can I see who voted for which tool?

Only if the poll is not anonymous. For the shortlist and the final pick, named votes are fine and help you follow up. For the trial survey, use anonymous so the feedback is honest.

Can I export the survey answers?

Yes. On Premium, the poll creator can export results to CSV from the poll settings.

Used by

From the help centre

Run your next poll in Slack

Simple Poll is the #1 polls and surveys app for Slack. 945,000+ teams use it. Free to start: type /poll and your first poll is live.

Add to Slack