Anonymous manager feedback survey for Slack

Upward feedback is the hardest feedback to give. People won't tell their manager what isn't working in a one-to-one, but many will in an anonymous survey with specific questions.

The survey only works if people trust that it's anonymous and see that something changes afterwards. Both are in your control.

When to use it
When a manager wants to know how they're doing from the people who report to them, and wants answers more honest than a one-to-one will get.
How often
Twice a year
Category
Feedback and engagement

Example polls

Paste any of these into the message box in Slack.

/poll "Feedback for your manager" "Anonymous. About two minutes." anonymous show results to creator close after 7 days remind 1 day before closing --- "My manager makes priorities and expectations clear" "Strongly disagree" "Disagree" "Neutral" "Agree" "Strongly agree" scale --- "My manager gives me useful feedback on my work" "Strongly disagree" "Disagree" "Neutral" "Agree" "Strongly agree" scale --- "My manager helps when I am stuck" "Strongly disagree" "Disagree" "Neutral" "Agree" "Strongly agree" scale --- "My manager supports my development" "Strongly disagree" "Disagree" "Neutral" "Agree" "Strongly agree" scale --- "What should your manager keep doing?" short text optional --- "What should your manager change?" short text optional

Survey (6 questions). The full upward feedback survey, results visible only to whoever creates it.

/poll "Feedback for your manager" "Anonymous. About two minutes." anonymous show results to creator close after 7 days remind 1 day before closing --- "My manager makes priorities and expectations clear" "Strongly disagree" "Disagree" "Neutral" "Agree" "Strongly agree" scale --- "My manager gives me useful feedback on my work" "Strongly disagree" "Disagree" "Neutral" "Agree" "Strongly agree" scale --- "My manager helps when I am stuck" "Strongly disagree" "Disagree" "Neutral" "Agree" "Strongly agree" scale --- "My manager supports my development" "Strongly disagree" "Disagree" "Neutral" "Agree" "Strongly agree" scale --- "What should your manager keep doing?" short text optional --- "What should your manager change?" short text optional

Premium: surveys (several questions), closing automatically, reminders, results for the creator only

AnonymousShow results: only visible to youClose automatically: after 7 daysReminder: 24 hours before closing

/poll "My manager gives me useful feedback on my work" "Strongly disagree" "Disagree" "Neutral" "Agree" "Strongly agree" scale anonymous

Scale from 1 to 5. One statement on Free, for a manager checking a single habit.

/poll "My manager gives me useful feedback on my work" "Strongly disagree" "Disagree" "Neutral" "Agree" "Strongly agree" scale anonymous

Free

Anonymous

/poll "I said I would change three things. Which has improved most?" "Shorter one-to-ones" "Clearer weekly priorities" "Faster code reviews" "None yet" anonymous limit 1 close after 3 days

Choice poll. The follow-up a few months later. Ask whether the changes landed.

/poll "I said I would change three things. Which has improved most?" "Shorter one-to-ones" "Clearer weekly priorities" "Faster code reviews" "None yet" anonymous limit 1 close after 3 days

Premium: vote limits, closing automatically

AnonymousLimit votes: 1 per personClose automatically: after 3 days

How to word it

Rate behaviours, not the person. "My manager gives me useful feedback on my work" is something a manager can change. "My manager is good" isn't.

Five or six statements is enough, on the same agree-disagree scale, covering:

  • Clear priorities and expectations
  • Useful feedback on my work
  • Support when I'm stuck
  • Recognition for good work
  • Interest in my development

Close with two optional free-text questions: what should they keep doing, and what should they change.

Make the anonymity real

Use anonymous. Nobody, the creator included, sees who answered what.

On a team of three, anonymity is thin no matter what the tool does: free-text answers give people away by their writing. Below about five reports, either drop the free text or combine teams under one skip-level manager.

For more distance, have someone from HR or People create the poll with show results to creator (Premium), so the results go to them first and they share the themes with the manager.

When to send it

Twice a year, away from performance reviews. Feedback collected in review season reads like a negotiation. Leave it open for a week, with close after 7 days (Premium) and a reminder before it closes.

What to do with the results

The manager should share the two or three main themes with the team, say what they'll change, and then do it. Rerun the same survey six months later. People keep answering only if the first round led somewhere.

Questions

Can the manager see who said what?

Not with anonymous. Nobody sees who answered what, including the poll's creator. On a very small team, free-text answers can still give people away, so keep that in mind.

Who should create the poll?

Whoever should see the raw results. If that's HR rather than the manager, have HR create it with show results to creator (Premium).

What needs Premium?

Multi-question surveys, show results to creator, limit, close after and reminders. Start a 14-day free trial with /simplepoll trial.

Used by

From the help centre

Run your next poll in Slack

Simple Poll is the #1 polls and surveys app for Slack. 945,000+ teams use it. Free to start: type /poll and your first poll is live.

Add to Slack