Controversial poll questions for work

A good controversial poll splits the team roughly in half over something that does not matter. Is a hot dog a sandwich? Should reply-all be banned? Nobody gets hurt, everyone has an opinion, and the thread underneath does the rest.

Below are 40 of them in four groups, all safe for work, plus how to post them in Slack with Simple Poll so the argument stays fun.

When to use it
When a social channel has gone quiet and you want a low-stakes debate that gets the whole team voting and arguing in the thread.
How often
Weekly
Category
Social and culture

Example polls

Paste any of these into the message box in Slack.

/poll "Is a hot dog a sandwich?" "Yes, obviously" :hotdog: "No, never" :x: "It is a taco" :taco: limit 1 order-results-by-votes

Choice poll. A classic food fight. One vote each, winning side on top (Premium for the vote limit).

/poll "Is a hot dog a sandwich?" "Yes, obviously" :hotdog: "No, never" :x: "It is a taco" :taco: limit 1 order-results-by-votes

Premium: vote limits

Limit votes: 1 per personOrder results: by most votes

/poll "Camera on or camera off for the first meeting of the day?" "Camera on" :movie_camera: "Camera off" :see_no_evil: "Depends who is in it" :thinking_face:

Choice poll. A meeting-norm debate with emoji options. Free.

/poll "Camera on or camera off for the first meeting of the day?" "Camera on" :movie_camera: "Camera off" :see_no_evil: "Depends who is in it" :thinking_face:

Free

/poll "What is your most controversial opinion about work?" short text :fire:

Short text with voting. Collect hot takes. People react with fire to the ones they agree with. Free.

/poll "What is your most controversial opinion about work?" short text :fire:

Free

Food fights

  • Does pineapple belong on pizza?
  • Is a hot dog a sandwich?
  • Cereal first or milk first?
  • Is cereal a soup?
  • Ketchup on eggs: fine or a crime?
  • Should toast be cut straight or diagonally?
  • Is it acceptable to eat someone's labelled leftovers if they have been there a week?
  • Fish in the office microwave: allowed or banned?
  • Is a Jaffa Cake a cake or a biscuit?
  • Do crisps belong in a sandwich?

Office etiquette debates

  • Is reply-all ever acceptable?
  • Cameras on or off in team meetings?
  • Is it rude to join a call two minutes late?
  • No agenda, no meeting: fair rule or too strict?
  • Is "per my last email" passive-aggressive?
  • Should you say "hi" and wait, or ask the question in the first message?
  • Is a thumbs-up reaction a valid reply?
  • Should meetings end five minutes early by default?
  • Is it fine to eat on camera?
  • Whose job is it to empty the dishwasher?

Unhinged hypotheticals

  • Could the team survive a week with no Slack, only email?
  • If we had to replace one meeting with an interpretive dance, which one?
  • Would you rather work with 100 duck-sized interns or one horse-sized intern?
  • Is a stand-up meeting still a stand-up if everyone sits?
  • Should the office have a nap pod or a slide?
  • If the coffee machine broke for a month, would you bring your own, switch to tea or work from home?
  • Should the company mascot be a pigeon?
  • Is a video call with no video technically a phone call?
  • If you could ban one word from all meetings forever, which one?
  • Should every shipped release earn cake?

Hot takes about work

  • Tabs or spaces?
  • Dark mode or light mode?
  • Is inbox zero a myth?
  • Are Friday afternoon deploys ever fine?
  • Is "quick call" ever quick?
  • Should Slack status emoji be mandatory?
  • Are standups better written than spoken?
  • Is a 9am meeting reasonable?
  • Should every document start with a summary?
  • Is the office whiteboard better than any app?

The line between a fun fight and a real one

The topic has to be trivial and the sides equal. Pineapple on pizza works because nobody is wrong and nobody is judged for their pick. Stay away from politics, religion, money, looks, age and anything tied to someone's background or job security. If losing the vote could make a person feel smaller, it is not a fun debate.

Watch the work-norm questions. "Cameras on or off?" and "Is a 9am meeting reasonable?" can touch real friction: childcare, time zones, people who find calls draining. They are worth asking, but post them as an honest question, not a joke at someone's expense.

Named votes for fun, anonymous for real questions

For food fights and hypotheticals, keep votes named. Seeing that your manager is firmly milk-first is half the point. When a question is about how the team actually works, such as replies after hours or meeting load, add anonymous so people vote what they think rather than what looks good.

Use limit 1 (Premium) so each person takes a side, and add order-results-by-votes so the winning side sits on top. Then ask people to defend their pick in the thread; the replies are where the fun is.

Collect hot takes, then vote on them

To gather the team's own hot takes, post a short text poll with a :fire: reaction. Everyone writes one opinion and fires the ones they agree with, so the most shared take is clear by the end of the day. The best ones become next week's polls.

Questions

What makes a good controversial poll question?

Two or three equally defensible sides on something trivial. Everyone should be able to vote in a second and argue for a minute. If one side is obviously right, it is not controversial; if it is personal, it is not harmless.

Which topics should I avoid?

Politics, religion, money, looks, age, health and anything about a real person on the team. Keep it to food, office habits and silly hypotheticals.

How often should I post one?

Once a week in a social channel is enough. For lighter questions without the debate, see funny poll questions for work or this or that questions.

Do these polls need a paid plan?

No. Choice polls with up to 5 options, emoji, anonymous, order-results-by-votes and short text with a reaction are free. One vote per person (limit 1) is Premium. Free has a monthly response limit; see pricing.

Run your next poll in Slack

Simple Poll is the #1 polls and surveys app for Slack. 945,000+ teams use it. Free to start: type /poll and your first poll is live.

Add to Slack